Medical model of care vs. Midwifery model of care

September 22nd, 2010 § 0 comments

I wrote this as a new midwifery student as part of my homework. Since I am studying for the NARM, I am going through all my homework to refresh my memory, and remind myself of things I have forgotten, and pick up on things I missed the first time through.

Explain the difference in the medical model of care and the midwifery model of care.
The midwifery model of care encourages women to trust in God’s elegant design of their bodies, and His design inherent in childbearing; it recognizes that conception, pregnancy, and birth are natural processes that God designed to function with minimal intervention. The female body is seen as unique, and normal. Midwives realize the value in good nutrition, exercise, and a wholesome lifestyle and supportive, healthy family relationships to promote good health and minimize complications. The midwifery model of care recognizes the mother as the only direct health-care provider for her unborn baby. When the mother is taking good care of herself, the baby will also be well-cared for. The midwifery model of care believes it is the client’s responsibility to make their own choices about tests and treatments, so midwives respect their clients by providing them with complete and accurate information for them to make informed health care decisions for themselves and their babies. Midwives seek to avoid practices and treatments based solely on fear, and instead seek to only carry out only those that have clear benefits for the mother and her baby. The process of pregnancy and birth is important to midwives, as well as the outcome. Midwives recognize that unnecessary interference can cause complications that would not otherwise occur, therefore they see themselves as guardians over these natural events and seasons, and intervene only as necessary for the health and well-being of the mother and baby. “One size fits all” does not apply to labor and birth; the midwife recognizes that each pregnancy, labor, and birth will be unique, and she is prepared and willing to be patient and flexible, allowing each woman’s body the time it needs to bring forth the baby, and in whatever positions are most effective. They also realize that spiritual and emotional issues can slow or stall labor, and they seek to resolve these, if at all possible. Midwives see pain in childbirth as a positive force because it brings forth a baby; they recognize that it is not a damaging pain, and therefore, it should not be feared. The midwifery model of care contends that mothers can birth just as safely, and more so, at a home or birth center, than in a hospital. The midwifery model of care sees birth as a personal, spiritual, and social event. Although in today’s world midwifery is viewed as “alternative” or “non-traditional”, until recent history, midwifery has been the traditional care—often the only care—for women worldwide.
The medical model of care sees pregnancy, labor, and birth as events that are fraught with dangers, and inherently pathological. They view the male body as the norm, and the female body as deviating from that. More often than not, the medical model offers fear-based care: in other words, they will intervene in the natural process to prevent certain complications, often causing other problems as they do so. The expectation, detection, and management of problems is foundational in the medical model of care. The expectation is that all births will need intervention. Mainstream medicine has a rather mechanical view of the body and treats symptoms rather than seeking to identify and treat the cause. They consult time charts to determine how long labor may take; they view deviations from these schedules as unsafe. If labor is slow or halting, Pitocin is used. The medical model of care values only the scientific—only that is can be measured or tested is viewed as useful information; the objective is valued, the subjective is mistrusted. In the medical model, the doctor is in charge and responsible for the outcome—as it is he who is making nearly all the decisions. The ultimate goal in mainstream medicine is to avoid death at all costs.

Resource: Holistic Midwifery by Anne Frye

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

What's this?

You are currently reading Medical model of care vs. Midwifery model of care at Joyful Midwifery.